Largest Selection
of Craft Beers

Our Menu

Inside Cardinal Pizza Shop Restaurant
Cardinal Pizza Shop

Testimonials

 I tried the Columbus style today and was blown away by how good it was. Tons of toppings, and very tasty.

As weird as it may sound they make their own bleu cheese in house, and I kid you not it’s the best I’ve eaten in my entire life. Absolutely an amazing compliment to their tasty wings.

– John Lee

Pizza Specials of the Month

Angry Bird

Spicy Arrabbiata sauce, fresh Mozz, Roasted jalapeno Peppers, Salami.

10″ – $ 16.25
14″ – $ 21.80

Chickolini

Garlic sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Broccolini, Whipped Ricotta. Finished with Sweet and sour Red onion.

10″ – $ 16.25
14″ – $ 21.80

Baby Bird

Original sauce, Oven Roasted Baby Portobello, caramelized onion, Finished with fresh pesto (nut free).

10″ – $ 14.00
14″ – $ 19.80

PARTIES

Cardinal Pizza Shop Parties

Chef baked catering for the whole crew!
Custom platters for any event!

Happy Hour!

Happy Hour

Monday – Friday 3:00 pm – 7:00 pm
Thursday 3:00 pm – 9:00 pm

School Fundraisers

Cardinal Pizza Shop School Fundraisers

We’ll donate 10% of sales from anyone
who mentions your organization!

Customer Reviews

They had the best pizza I’ve ever had since I moved to Ohio. Certainly a MUST try.
Chloe Milbert
Chloe Milbert
18:29 16 Jun 24
Small place but great food. I’m not a pizza guy but they have good pizza. Busy place on a snowy Friday.
Todd Atkins
Todd Atkins
14:57 05 Feb 22
I've only gotten their basic pepperoni with banana peppers but it is fantastic. One of my favorites in the city.
Brian J.
Brian J.
04:42 11 Jun 24
Went there because of the fourth Friday celebration in the Westerville location service was pretty good product was really good as well we will definitely be back
Tony G.
Tony G.
01:56 25 May 24
Im from the east coast (NY area) where they actually make real food. I wont eat anywhere else. The food is gr8. Ignore the whiners, that complain about the occasional hiccup.
No place Id rather be.
FACT.
Mike Wickham
Mike Wickham
10:46 05 Feb 22
Had a gluten free pepperoni pizza delivered with regular sauce and extra pep.I have ceiac and did NOT get sickGood job! It was really good!Delivery...
Joanie V.
Joanie V.
19:07 12 May 24
We order from them regularly (atleast once a week). Food is always exceptional. I'm obsessed with their ranch dressing and I'm not usually a fan of others. What I really love is their staff. All of our delivery drivers are awesome. And the kitchen... staff have always paid close attention to my "notes". I love them forever!! We've never been in the restaurant, but I hope to one day because I hear good things!read more
Sarah Smith
Sarah Smith
04:01 04 May 24
Had a 10” half pepperoni half onion NewYork style pizza with the spicy sauce ! Absolutely bursting with flavor and delicious.. the sauce , cheese and crust are spot on and being from Connecticut I know good pizza ! Their garlic cheese bread was... delicious also . My new go to pizza place . Service was friendly , prompt and reasonably priced ! Where have you been my whole life ? Lol 😋😋👍read more
Kathleen Sullivan
Kathleen Sullivan
01:05 26 Jan 22
Best New York Style pizza @ Chus without a question!I loved the small town ambiance and the attention, specially from the owners God bless you...
William M.
William M.
15:30 01 Feb 24
Freaking great pizza and subs...I got nothin else to say. Just freakin great
Mike Black
Mike Black
17:36 07 Apr 24
Your professionalism, genuine kindness and bluntness at times when I needed to face reality are what made me progress. I invested $550 with Miss Edna Albert,and got $7200 in a week. I only wish I had known about her earlier from the first moment I... decided to trade. Nevertheless, I am grateful!
contact her via
Email:ednaalbert943@gmail.com
WhatsApp: +1 (314) 649-8594
read more
Chinyere Amadi
Chinyere Amadi
04:51 04 Jan 22
This is my favorite pizza shop in Columbus. Why? First I love the vibe. Its a small shop and I mean right now its small and truly, I love that. However,...
Laura F.
Laura F.
17:42 16 Dec 23
Very nice establishment, pizza was delicious and prices are great
KAREN Kimbro
KAREN Kimbro
19:41 01 Apr 24
Went here last night and had the absolute most delicious pizza that Bob the owner and Bill the Manager helped us create. 1 large customized pizza and 6 beers was a total of $55 including the 20% tip, which we thought was a steal considering the... quality, drink options, speedy service, and fun atmosphere on a Saturday night. I am so excited to go back and experiment some more with different toppings. 10/10!read more
Lacey Meeks
Lacey Meeks
15:51 12 Sep 21
Ended up going here to grab a pizza for the Browns vs Cardinals game. Ironic, isn't it? But, unlike the Cardinals football team, this pizza is not slouch....
LJ W.
LJ W.
04:10 20 Nov 23
Wow a packed house last night, love it!! Amazing pizza NY style 😋 and chzy garlic bread!!#RIPBobby
Bobbi Jo Fields
Bobbi Jo Fields
18:56 03 Mar 24
the atmosphere was so charming, it's a small pizza shop but the food was super good and everyone was so friendly!! I absolutely recommend.
Stopped in to catch the OSU football game. They have a great beverage selection and their pizza was delicious!!! Small space but very accommodating! Our...
Andrea M.
Andrea M.
12:56 15 Sep 23
Had a large order that I placed on behalf of my client. Sarah was great to make all the arrangements. The "Red Bird" special (18" NY Style pizza with 8 pie slices- what I am used to from my hometown of WNY). A little hiccup the day of the planned... delivery (think another party had confused with a time change request) with running a little behind, however, the delivery driver was very courteous and followed through on his promise of texting the additional receipt for expense purposes. The pizza was "gobbled up" - no leftovers (a total of 64 slices went in 15 minutes for 50 people). One of the attendees from New Jersey commented on how good it was and he identified as a "pizza snob". Thank you Cardinal.read more
Tracy Zglinicki
Tracy Zglinicki
13:22 09 Feb 24
First time having their pizza and wings - both were amazing!
Emily Swanson
Emily Swanson
23:14 24 Jun 21
Excellent pizza! Great seasoning! Awesome service! This was my second time visiting Cardinal Pizza although I had tasted it before and I must say that they...
Reginald L.
Reginald L.
13:42 07 Sep 23
Very good 1st time experience 👍🏾 love supporting small businesses
Dee Lloyd
Dee Lloyd
21:37 24 Jan 24
tried the New York style pizza is was good. will come back to try the Columbus style next
Blaine Emmert
Blaine Emmert
05:08 20 Jun 21
First impression visit. Good pizza. Ample public parking. Convenient texting when carryout is ready. 5 dine in tables with an expansion in the future. 10...
Tom H.
Tom H.
19:31 26 Aug 23
I love the pizza. I also really enjoy that I call and place and order and pay with cash. It really skips the hassle of having to order online or involve a 3rd party.
MuffaLotta
MuffaLotta
20:40 08 Jan 24
Great Pizza and service!😋❤️
Laura McCoy
Laura McCoy
17:28 12 Jun 21
Friends recommended trying this pizza. I can honestly say it's the best in Westerville. I ordered a build your own 14 inch NY style with pepperoni,...
Sara I.
Sara I.
17:59 14 Aug 23
We in town for the weekend and stopped for lunch.. everything was fantastic. The salad with the pepperoni on it was SO good- especially with the creamy Italian. Our New York style pepperoni pizza was cooked perfectly and had so much flavor. Great... service as well!! 10/10 recommendread more
Sydney Mack
Sydney Mack
17:30 02 Dec 23
Tonight in the A-Z pizza challenge we are up to letter C. This was my favorite so far. The five cheese pizza was delicious. The Gov-na was extra sauce extra cheese and extra pep. The pep was perfect. Crispy and spicy. Appetizer was birdy bread.... My 9 year old picky eater gave it a 5 out of 5. Beer selection was really good.

My only complaint was the Italian sub. It was over toasted. I was sad because it used creamy Italian dressing which would have been game changer. It also lacked meat compared to other places. Dessert was apple pie filling baked in a pizza crust with streusel topping.

I would recommend take out as it is very small. A bar and two tables.

Staff extremely friendly!
read more
Kim Bremer Sammons
Kim Bremer Sammons
23:26 08 May 21
Good pizza, nothing more. Crust is good but the New York style pizza doesn't have the thin New York style crust.
Scott J.
Scott J.
16:20 12 Aug 23
Great spot for a few drinks and of course the best pizza around
Darrek Robertson
Darrek Robertson
17:47 28 Oct 23
i like there food it's a great little place
Best pizza in Westervill hands down! Also, if you're looking for a great cocktail for a reasonable cost, this is your spot. My boyfriend and I love coming...
Maggie M.
Maggie M.
22:07 15 Jul 23
Asked some locals for a good place and was sent here. The pizza was amazing, the service was amazing. We grabbed an Italian Sub and some wings also. Everything wr had was perfectly cold and served hot.The bartender/ server was excellent and on top... of things. I would highly recommend.read more
Rob Towell
Rob Towell
18:25 15 Oct 23
great place, good people and amazing food...highly recommend
Marc Humker
Marc Humker
16:34 24 Feb 21
Delicious pizza. 1st time trying it. Delivery. Took 1 hour but that was expected. Excellent red sauce. Crust very good. Large Pepperoni, Red Onion and black...
Alli B.
Alli B.
19:04 20 Apr 23
$2 pep slice...say no more!
Blakk Sonni
Blakk Sonni
18:47 21 Sep 23
The service and food was very outstanding. Plenty of choices to choose from. Pizza, drinks, salads, wings, subs, and much more. I’ll definitely be back. Thanks for the great lunch Bob.

Mike & Lynae’
From Marion, Ohio
Michael Jolliff
Michael Jolliff
20:37 10 Feb 21
Fantastic place to try. Very small eating area but worth looking or waiting for a spot. Great prices on drinks and food is great. Love their pizzas -...
Marebear B.
Marebear B.
04:52 27 Jan 23
Small and charming pizza shop with a large menu. We had meatballs, salad, and pizza. All of the food was great.
Lacey Bennett
Lacey Bennett
18:22 09 Sep 23
Ordered the Govn'a with mushrooms on GF crust and it was AMAZING! Also delivered 25 minutes early....SCORE!
Claudine Hill-Bryant
Claudine Hill-Bryant
22:04 16 Jan 21
Great pizza. Went here for lunch so it wasn't super crowded. Cold beer and piping hot pizza with tons of pepperoni. Give this place a shot if you are in...
Tricia W.
Tricia W.
12:40 11 Dec 22
Best pizza in westerville (world)
michael albert
michael albert
00:38 04 Sep 23
I want to give Cardinal Pizza very high marks, but our food was ice cold when we got it home and we picked it up at the recommended time or earlier and did not live far so it should have been warmer than it was, not remotely hot. The consistent... comment around the table was that this would have been delicious if it was even warm. We got a 10 inch pep New York style pizza, Meatball Sub, Stallion Sub, two 6 piece boneless chicken and three salads, two specialty salads with poppy seed dressing and one house, salads were good size portions. Pizza had a nice olive oil taste on the crust but cheese was cold so that was a disappointment, boneless chicken had good flavor but hardly any sauce at all and ice cold. Italian sub and meatball held up better, luke warm and tasty but would be better hot. Really nice people, left a $5 tip, rethinking that now but with COViD everyone in the restaurant business deserves a little extra.read more
Eric J. Kaster
Eric J. Kaster
03:26 21 Dec 20
Great my style pizza. But you have to get them to cook xtra long as standard cook does not crunch up center of pie
Tim D.
Tim D.
11:35 16 Oct 22
The staff and food is amazing!! Best Hawaiian pizza I ever had 😌
Cameron L
Cameron L
23:41 22 Aug 23
love it and the food was awesome service was top notch
Seanene Owens
Seanene Owens
00:37 18 Dec 20
Walked in, sat down and was soon satisfied. There are two types of pies: NY and Columbus. Columbus has more of a Donatos style thin, square cut crust...
Rich G.
Rich G.
15:59 04 Oct 22
9 employee's at Worthington Automotive guarantee Cardinal's has the best specialty pizzas on earth! If your looking for the best bang for the buck then get the 18" double pep double cheese. Nicest restaurant employees around also.
Worthington Automotive
Worthington Automotive
15:13 31 Jul 23
Fabulous fresh toppings and amazing owner. They made a mistake on one of my pizzas and the owner brought us a new one right away.
Robyne Vasselo
Robyne Vasselo
00:37 18 Dec 20
We moved to Westerville about a year ago and started trying different pizza places every week or two. Cardinal pizza is one that we have returned to again...
Sherry C.
Sherry C.
20:17 30 Sep 22
Great pizza. VERY small dining area/bar, we had to order our food to go. I would have preferred to dine in.
Emily Masonheimer
Emily Masonheimer
21:49 14 Jul 23
Great Pizza and wings. Friendly staff!
Robert Spence
Robert Spence
01:28 01 Nov 20
We finally had the chance to check out Cardinal Pizza shop on Saturday and I'm so glad we did! We had a large NY style cheese pizza, breadsticks, a thin...
Sarah W.
Sarah W.
05:25 26 Sep 22
Amazing fresh toppings and exciting choices. The owner is local and will bend over backwards to provide great food and top notch customer service.
Robyne Vasselo
Robyne Vasselo
23:49 27 Jun 23
Great Pizza and awesome service
David Parsons
David Parsons
07:28 30 Oct 20
4th Friday in uptown Westerville tonight and swung by Cardinal for a white pie. AMAZING NY style, fresh ricotta, garlic buttery goodness on a chewy crust.
Rachel R.
Rachel R.
18:00 22 Jul 22
Seriously the best pizza in Columbus. Reasonable prices, fun little place to dine in and great service.Always a treat to go there and eat.Highly recommend and check it out!
Anne Mandell
Anne Mandell
01:42 10 Jun 23
The Tower pizza is the best. Nice hometown place, good food, great service!
Leslie Sheridan
Leslie Sheridan
04:24 23 Oct 20
YUM!! New York style pizza with lots of toppings. The white pizza is fantastic. One of the best pizzas in Columbus!
Rachel R.
Rachel R.
18:33 27 Jun 22
So small...easily packed on the weekends. Wasn't able to enjoy the atmosphere like I wanted. Pizza is always very good.
Michelle Collins
Michelle Collins
11:28 21 May 23
top notch pizza and service! Small bar at the entrance if you want a cold waiting.
Joseph D. Ferraro
Joseph D. Ferraro
00:49 21 Oct 20
Wow! Great thing for the kids and they all need help. Thank goodness I was just checking to make sure the price is still available for me.
William M.
William M.
15:19 25 Jun 22
Excellent happy hour deals and great food to compliment the drinks. Consider this place for sure if passing through or visiting the nearby college.
oliverw24
oliverw24
23:57 02 May 23
Great little local pizza shop.
Andrea Armstrong
Andrea Armstrong
00:52 25 Sep 20
As far as NYC style pizza in Westerville/CBUS, this is as good as it gets. It was really good.
Will E.
Will E.
12:24 10 Apr 22
Natalie is awesome
Francis Gearing
Francis Gearing
02:51 22 May 24
new favorite pizza .. the New York style is out of this world!!!
Cassy C. Sager
Cassy C. Sager
16:47 30 Aug 20
Amazing. Definitely one of the best pizza shops in the Columbus area. They also have amazing happy hour specials.
Ron F.
Ron F.
12:02 12 Mar 22
Food is excellent, the place is small so it's hard to get a good atmosphere. Carry out and you can't go wrong
Paul Riddle
Paul Riddle
14:43 22 Mar 24
Tried this place today after a friend recommended it. Pizza is excellent, service was fast! Will be ordering here again
Mike Volpini
Mike Volpini
18:51 29 Aug 20
Stopped in after having a couple drinks.Got the Columbus style Guv'Nah. This is some really cool Columbus style pizza.Lots of crispy pepperoni, good...
Elijah B.
Elijah B.
06:59 27 Feb 22
Just started eating here and WOW the pizza is really good NY style is excellent!
Dennis Foley
Dennis Foley
14:15 15 Jan 24
Picked it up for the first time tonight and it’s now my new favorite place. Both the New York style and the Columbus style were delicious! 😃
Erin-Marie Christine
Erin-Marie Christine
22:05 22 Aug 20
Excellent pizza. Crust was delicious. We got the Ohio crust. Would definitely return.
Renee J.
Renee J.
18:28 28 Nov 21
Tiny inside hard to get a table but most are Togo orders. Pizza is really good New York style. They do a Columbus style too but never had it.
Henry Derstine
Henry Derstine
14:33 23 Oct 23
Awesome pizza! 🍕The best I’ve had in a long time! ❤️ Great wings too! And stellar service. We’re already planning to go back 🤓
Renata Reaume-Mazei
Renata Reaume-Mazei
02:26 14 Aug 20
This is our new spot in Westerville. We prefer the NY Crust over the Columbus, but order here weekly. Great carry out spot that can get busy if you don't...
Patrick M.
Patrick M.
15:07 28 Nov 21
Great NY Pizza, 👍 wings are great and amazing staff.
Eliezer Lebron
Eliezer Lebron
01:45 09 Sep 23
Great food, local art work on the walls,
scratch made items, fun list of drinks and spirits infusions! had great service, worth the stop!
New favorite pizza place. Stopped in one night on the way to my parents and it's VERY tiny inside so social distancing is kind of hard. There are a couple...
Trina W.
Trina W.
14:07 18 Nov 21
Great food, relaxed friendly atmosphere! I cannot say a bad thing about the food or experiences I have had to date. I love the Margherita pizza. The wings are excellent as well.
Matthew Daas
Matthew Daas
04:34 28 Jul 23
Great pizza, great subs, great people!
Glad to have them in our community!
Andrew 'Bud' Streetman
Andrew 'Bud' Streetman
22:47 16 Apr 20
4 stars for now, could be borderline 5.NY style was good, probably even better in person, salads were fresh and tasty. Garlic cheesy bread cheesy and...
Patrick M.
Patrick M.
15:07 19 Sep 21
Excellent all-around pizza joint! Great happy hour or just stop for a DORA drink to go.
J. Yeeeengeeeeer
J. Yeeeengeeeeer
03:51 02 Jun 23
The pizza is amazing. Quality ingredients, amazing specialty pizzas and so delicious!
Kristen Sluss
Kristen Sluss
03:04 08 Apr 20
I'll save you some time and just suggest you get the Pizza My Heart, it's what keeps me coming back here. Also it's a great neighborhood hangout, you'll...
Dan D.
Dan D.
16:17 18 Sep 21
Their pizza and subs are terrific. 11/10.
Amanda Bentivegna
Amanda Bentivegna
00:28 28 Apr 24
Some of the best pies around never disappoints!
Jon Koenig
Jon Koenig
04:52 15 Feb 20
This place was recommended to us. We found 2 places that ended up being our Family favs here. This place is one of them. Big pizzas,no skimping on the...
Sandy M.
Sandy M.
18:18 29 May 21
This has a great small town vibe! The pizza is really good, the staff is friendly, there are TVs over the (full) bar, and it's fun. They do a large carry out business and it's also nice to eat there but you should go early as there are only a few... tables.read more
Judy Sharpe-Kosmatka
Judy Sharpe-Kosmatka
18:04 24 Sep 23
I ordered their Italian sub and a Columbus crust pizza. The bread for their subs is amazing. I always prefer a creamy Italian dressing as well, which they have. The ham looked like thick sliced ham from a Christmas ham, not packaged water ham. The... pizza is typical of a Columbus pizza place, but the flavor is definitely it's own. Good ingredients and a great crust and sauce flavor. I am immediately impressed. And it's in the old Classic spot in uptown Westerville. That spot needs a good pizza place in it.read more
Doug Gray
Doug Gray
21:56 02 Feb 20
The pizza was really good, the service was great. They have a good happy hour. But the Club Sub missed the mark. It was pretty plain, barely any bacon and...
Shawna S.
Shawna S.
16:40 31 Mar 21
Great meatball sub and pizzas. Cool peeps!
Stephen Steen
Stephen Steen
15:30 13 May 23
Local and they have amazing cauliflower crust! Seriously, the best I have ever had!
Bethany Vosburg-Bluem
Bethany Vosburg-Bluem
23:27 26 Jan 20
Update 02/28/21: we just had Cardinal Pizza a couple of times over the past month, they have definitely fine-tuned some things since my last review,...
Justin K.
Justin K.
06:24 28 Feb 21
I'm so happy I found their NY style pizza recently. It is great.
Lynn Rideout
Lynn Rideout
04:07 28 Feb 24
We ordered a couple of pizzas and subs last night and both were delicious! You can tell Cardinal uses quality, fresh ingredients. The subs were extra good—great bun and well put together so it didn’t fall apart. We will be back.
Sharon Hess Rich
Sharon Hess Rich
14:44 05 Jan 20
We got a large pizza and an order of 12 boneless wings, both of which were honestly incredible. There have been complaints about long wait times, and when...
Joey S.
Joey S.
07:59 13 Feb 21
Cool spot (love the small bar area), good pizza, friendly people
Tod Bowen
Tod Bowen
12:53 27 May 24
the pizza is excellent and the staff is great
Todd Upton
Todd Upton
19:16 21 Oct 19
best ny style pizza in cbus buff chick dip slaps too
jenna cruickshanks
jenna cruickshanks
05:13 17 May 24
Cardinal pizza is a great place to connect with friends while enjoying the delicious pizza and sandwiches in a Mediterranean surroundings from my photography collection, going on now trough October 31st.
I like to thank the owners for giving me... the opportunity to display my artwork!🖼read more
Mariangela Scavo Manno
Mariangela Scavo Manno
14:01 05 Oct 19
Got a delivery tonight and everything was great!! Highly recommended
ILIAS STROVOLIDIS
ILIAS STROVOLIDIS
01:58 23 Apr 24
pizza is truly new york style!
Katie Cupp
Katie Cupp
03:09 16 Sep 19
This was some of the absolute BEST pizza I've had in my life! I'm excited to try more from it!
Vanessa Hock
Vanessa Hock
20:18 03 Apr 24
SO good! We just had a New York style pizza delivered to our office. Lived it! My new favorite pizza in Westerville! And the customer service was outstanding. Easy order process online, affordable and quick delivery, and driver was fantastic. ... Thank you!read more
Amy Safarik Goings
Amy Safarik Goings
16:54 30 Aug 19
Im from Brooklyn and when I had that pizza, it took me all the way back to my childhood. Not many places still making pizza like this. A1 NY slice.
Evelyn Reddick
Evelyn Reddick
20:12 20 Mar 24
the pizza was great made in to my top 5 definitely going back
Mark Shank
Mark Shank
22:56 18 Jul 19
Amazing pizza. I ordered online and it was ready at the exact time given.Service was quick and friendly and I was able to just run in and pick it up fast.I was impressed by the flavor. Crust, sauce, toppings... everything was delicious. The NY... style crust is amazing. I'm so glad I decided to try it.I will definitely be back soon.read more
Jameliah Brown
Jameliah Brown
23:48 22 Feb 24
I am a Jersey Girl, born & raised and it is difficult to find good East Coast authentic Italian pizza in Ohio. Cardinal hits the nail on n the head. Super fast & friendly too!
Jean Tully
Jean Tully
22:55 25 Jun 19
Cheers 1️⃣❤️
Joe Glinski
Joe Glinski
22:54 29 Jan 24
We had a great experience this afternoon at Cardinal Pizza. We had a large party and they accommodated us all. The staff was friendly and the service was quick and great. We ordered several different styles of pizza and wings and it was all so good.... Will definitely go back!!! Great job and welcome to the neighborhood!read more
Jonathan N Kim Nieves
Jonathan N Kim Nieves
23:18 09 Jun 19
My husbands loves loves this pizza i also do to he is just obsessed. They have exstremly good service. I have never ate inside but i alwsy pickup our pizza and its looks like a great atmosphere they have a bar tvs and tables and alwsys full of... people no matter what day of the week. We alwsy order thr new york style which is 18 in huge pizza huge slices, its cut in triangles and is thinner pizza. They have diffrent options that i would love to try. I also get the birdie bread hands down best breads sticks i ever have had. Seasoned very good. I really love this pizza place i live out east in columbus so its like 20 min from my house and worth the drive.read more
layli bug
layli bug
23:11 09 Jan 24
Best pizza we’ve had in a long time!
Kelsey Shawn Fent
Kelsey Shawn Fent
01:53 05 Jun 19
Dine in or take out, love it! That Stallion is a rockstar!!!
Todd Bottorff
Todd Bottorff
19:44 15 Dec 23
Were so glad we found this pizza place! It’s our new go-to! Everything always tastes so fresh and we LOVE the sauce!
Nicole Dodds
Nicole Dodds
22:54 01 Jun 19
SUNDAY BRUNCH WAS UNBELIEVABLE 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯The sauce was epic, sausage was top quality and cooked to perfection.The flipping love in the potatoes!! You can't fake good food and this is GOOD FOOD.... Lock eyes with... that egg for a moment.read more
DVS Customs
DVS Customs
17:57 12 Nov 23
Love their pizza, salads and Portabella mushroom so I will let them take over the meeting and the meeting will ge Portabella mushroom sub!!!
Mary Gray
Mary Gray
19:47 30 May 19
Fantastic NY style pizza, best in Columbus. Great service. 4 tables and about 8 seats at the bar. Street parking.
beth ders
beth ders
16:39 21 Oct 23
great addition to uptown westerville! Got a pizza and a sub and both were great, I highly recommend stopping in and giving it try!
Shane Wells
Shane Wells
01:07 23 May 19
Simply delicious pizza
Tracie Pearson
Tracie Pearson
08:16 24 Sep 23
We ordered takeout for our friends and family and were very pleased!! The staff was very friendly and the food was excellent!! Highly recommend!
Kaitlyn Flynn
Kaitlyn Flynn
02:19 20 May 19
Our favorite pizza place in Westerville. Their Italian sub is fantastic. Pizza is top notch and they have the best gluten-free crust if you have anyone with allergies.
Matthew Mulvane
Matthew Mulvane
17:58 11 Sep 23
I’m from New York and they make a great NY pizza. They also have cauliflower crust for gluten free and keto people. Great place!!
Sherry Apone Penree
Sherry Apone Penree
18:25 18 May 19
First time trying this pizzeria, trying to find a decent New York style pizza. We tried their Margherita and Pepperoni NY style pizza along with Old School salad and Buffalo wings. Food was ordered for takeout, food was fresh, taste was great, and... overall impressed.I'm giving five stars because this pizzeria is in Ohio.My personal opinion it is all about ingredients but more importantly the water. There is something special about NYC Cannonsville water supply. I have yet to find the dough comparable to NYC's pizza.With that said Cardinal Pizza was spot on with quality of their ingredients, along with the obvious detailed love & care that they put into their food and drinks.read more
Brian Bury
Brian Bury
21:05 05 Sep 23
Try the spicy sauce! Yum!
Casey Sims Knowles
Casey Sims Knowles
22:13 21 Oct 19
Solid choice for pizza in Uptown Westerville. Garlic bread sticks with Marinara were tasty, though noticably salty. Columbus-style pizza was accurate, Massey's style but not as liberal with the cornmeal under the crust, and yummy with a hint of... spice, very similar to Flyers. The place is small inside, and the pickup counter is all the way in the back, so they can let the bar focus on bar stuff - smart.read more
Monica Bower
Monica Bower
11:33 23 Aug 23
One of the best pizza’s I’ve ever had. Add in the great Italian sub and you have yourself a deadly combo
Tyler Mautz
Tyler Mautz
00:27 05 Oct 19
Cardinal Pizza was a fantastic find in the heart of downtown Westerville, Ohio. The pizza was great, atmosphere was fun, and they were quick with the lunch takeout order on top of it all.Pizza was perfectly cooked (thin crust was wonderful), but... you can not visit and not pickup the bread sticks. These were honestly the best bread sticks I have ever had. They were perfectly seasoned, loaded with butter and garlic, and were incredible.We'll definitely be stopping here on our next trip to the area.read more
Alex Curnes
Alex Curnes
21:07 08 Aug 23
If you like thin and crispy pizza try the Columbus style pizza..... FANTASTIC! It’s our new FAVORITE!!! So GOOD!!!
First time ordering from this restaurant, it has its own very special taste. Nice piece of art. We definitely GOT AFTER IT when it arrived.
LaTasha La'Ria
LaTasha La'Ria
11:22 25 Jul 23
Pizza by the slice 11-2! Great food, community oriented ownership. A nice addition to the local food options.
Andrew Piper
Andrew Piper
19:30 21 Jun 19
This pizza is not to be missed .. I ordered New York style crust with the tower topping .. delicious . Small area to grab a beer and eat in . Highly recommend .
Teri Wolff
Teri Wolff
23:17 01 Jul 23
Enjoyed their pizza at Good Vibes in Westerville. #GoodVibesWinery.
April Schaad
April Schaad
21:20 03 Jun 19
Best pizza in the Ville
James Helkey
James Helkey
00:06 14 Jun 23
chefs make the best pizza. Bob is one of the most talented chefs I have had the pleasure of cooking with
Adam Lang
Adam Lang
21:22 29 May 19
This is the best pizza in Central Ohio. Try the “Baller” it is amazing, Looking forward to trying the Sunny brunch.
Tim Tomesek
Tim Tomesek
22:39 30 May 23
Great Pizza and Wings!! Had the Pizza my heart, a 1/2 pep 1/2 cheese, and some Chili Teriyaki wings. Great atmosphere and very clean.
Tiffany Hamilton
Tiffany Hamilton
21:49 19 May 19
Nice filled subs
Cheryl Trevethan
Cheryl Trevethan
20:42 07 May 23
Ordered delivery on Saturday night and it delivered quick and hot. I ordered the pizza Columbus style and it is phenomenal. Great crisp to it, great tasting sauce and they load up the toppings. Very good addition to Westerville. Our families new go... to pizza!read more
Douglas James Morris
Douglas James Morris
13:11 20 Oct 19
I have only gotten the pepperoni with banana peppers pizza but it's friggin delicious. Easily one of my favorites in the city.
Brian Johnson
Brian Johnson
11:43 11 Jun 24
Ok so here is my official take on Cardinal. Love the Columbus Style pepperoni pizza with the old skool pepperoni that cups with grease, this is the style you want. The New York style is OK, it lacks toppings in comparison to the Columbus style and... barely felt like a pizza was in the box. They brag about it being so cheap for such a large pizza, but it tastes cheap. If I was Cardinal I would loose the New York style and make the Columbus style pizzas in a bigger size, now that would be amazing. The wings are OK the sauces are what the chef needs to work on, they need a spicy garlic sauce. The lady that always takes my order and is there when I pay is so sweet and so nice I wish the rest of the staff reflected her values. Many of the guys in the back, especially the guy with glasses making the pizzas, looks dirty and unkempt and seem to not follow directions very well. I love this new pizza shop they just need to make a few tweaks and get more consistent on their product.read more
Craig Dunn
Craig Dunn
12:27 03 Jul 19
Great pizza with an awesome atmosphere. Great beer selection between domestics and local craft beer. Although I didn't partake in any bourbon, they have a few bottles that gave me second thoughts. The place gets pretty packed with only one.or two... people serving everyone.read more
Jacob Rorabaugh
Jacob Rorabaugh
16:19 07 Apr 24
Amazing! Just ate a NY style pepperoni for dinner. Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Do yourself a favor and melt a little butter with a pinch of salt and garlic powder to dip the crust into. This will be our new spot. Prices are better then what... I would expect. So happy that a new place has arrived and I think this one is going to stick.read more
Sarah Austing Cochrane
Sarah Austing Cochrane
00:30 01 Jun 19
The pizza and wings were so good!
Kara Bailey
Kara Bailey
20:13 30 Jan 24
Great job... friendly staff, welcoming atmosphere... awesome pizza!
Zachary Martin
Zachary Martin
18:22 17 May 19
Love this place.
Adrian Coleman
Adrian Coleman
01:48 30 Nov 23
Decided to stop in and try a slice with my boyfriend. We order a large thin crust with pepperoni (banana peppers on my half) and a Stallion Sub. I was pleasantly surprised by how crackly the crust was, where as some thin crusts are hard and crunchy.... The pepperoni had a nice crispy edge around each one and the cheese added great flavor and was super stretchy! The sub had a nicely toasted bun that didn’t wilt the veg inside and the creamy Italian dressing on it tied the whole thing together. The atmosphere was casual yet cozy with its sharp decor and pops of red; like a modern family pizzeria vibe. Definitely will be going back!read more
Ashley Stone Fetherolf
Ashley Stone Fetherolf
20:31 05 Jun 19
Great place and great food. I can't wait until the expansion into the building next door and will have more seating
Blaine Emmert
Blaine Emmert
17:04 16 Sep 23
They did a great job of feeding our rehearsal dinner wedding party with 21 pizzas! On time delivery of hot, delicious pizza. It has officially joined the rotation!
Jamie McKenna
Jamie McKenna
15:14 14 Sep 19
The meatball sub was absolutely excellent. Buffalo chicken dip was good but I didn't think it was anything special.
wardtr2239 TW
wardtr2239 TW
01:52 18 Aug 23
New pizza shop in Westerville! Impressed. Ordered a 10” GF (“gluten friendly” - cauliflower crust) with pep, onion, pineapple, and extra cheese. Also did a 14” Columbus style thin crust pie - half plain cheese, other half with pep, sausage, fresh... jalepeño, and onion. Both pizzas were delicious. I enjoyed the cauliflower crust just as much if not more than the regular pie (slightly more cooked / crispier). Pies look great, taste great - slammed them both! We’ll be back! Give them a shot - 614-423-8717. We had ours delivered. Only complaint is that they forgot to double cut the regular pie (8 giant slices) but I didn’t mind.read more
Andy Dunn
Andy Dunn
20:59 20 May 19
Pizza was delicious- service was awesome! Little cheesecake (salted caramel) was great too!
Marissa Klimenko
Marissa Klimenko
01:03 27 Jun 23
great food and service, if you want pizza Uptown, this is your best choice
Scott Anderson
Scott Anderson
23:34 22 Oct 19
One pizza was a little overdone but otherwise yum
Mardie Laughlin
Mardie Laughlin
18:35 21 Dec 23
Was stopped for the night and found this little gem. Ordered over the phone and picked it up and took back to the hotel. Wow, this was definitely one of the best pizzas I have had. Love the old Town feel also.
Fred Sitzes
Fred Sitzes
11:03 03 Jul 23
First time ordering Cardinal. Had a couple special requests, staff bent over backwards to make it happen. Pizza was great!
John Silvestri
John Silvestri
19:23 03 Sep 23
This was my second time having the Spin Dip pizza with Columbus crust. I’ve been craving it since the first time I had it! It is amazing! It’s a special for the month of April but I’m really hoping they will keep it on the menu!!!
Jackie Knox
Jackie Knox
03:16 30 Apr 23